Questioning Artificial Minds and Bodies: Who is Human?
Overview
How do you know you’re human? No, seriously, how do you know that you are a person? Emotions? Personality? Consciousness? While these things do contribute to your humanity, when you enter the cyberpunk world, this is turned upside down. Artificial intelligence longs to be recognized as life, and humans want to escape their physical forms. The lines are blurred, and the scriptwriter determines your fate. The integral cyberpunk works we have studied in class, William Gibson’s Neuromancer and Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner, build worlds that give the reader the opportunity to truly question what it means to be human. Through challenging cognitive, biological, and physical definitions of humanity, these works contribute to an integral concern of the cyberpunk genre: what counts as consciousness?
Questioning Artificial Consciousness
Neuromancer follows a drug addict and skilled hacker, Henry Case. In this dystopian future, he is living as a hustler in Chiba City with a damaged nervous system that prevents his entrance into cyberspace, where he was able to use his skills. He is given an offer to fix his nervous system and enter cyberspace in exchange for agreeing to pull off a heist for an ex-military officer, Armitage. He fixes his issue but is also implanted with a poison that Armitage will only disarm if the job is completed. This is the setup for the great plot that we see play out in the book. Looking specifically at our main character, Case, he devalues his physical body, referring to it as meat and preferring the liberating feeling of being in cyberspace. Although we might think that our physical body makes us human, he values the humanity of his consciousness. Looking at the artificial intelligences that he interacts with, Wintermute and Neuromancer, they have different personalities (if you would call them that), with a goal of merger to be more whole and autonomous. However, the Tessier-Ashpool family, via the Turing Registry, aims to restrict this merger. Allowing these AIs to merge would allow them to be above human authority, which disrupts the current hierarchy of this world. AI is meant to be a tool for humans to use, not to have a true consciousness of its own. In Neuromancer, we see the questioning of artificial minds. However, Blade Runner questions artificial bodies.
Questioning Artificial Bodies
Blade Runner was created in 1982, yet is set in 2019 in Los Angeles. However, this is a dystopian version of the city, where our main character, Rick Deckard, is a retired “blade runner.” In this job, he tracked down replicants, which are humanoids that are bioengineered. He is tasked with hunting down and killing four replicants who are illegally on Earth: Leon, Roy, Zohar, and Pris. This sets our plot in motion and follows Deckard on this hunt. In this film, we see multiple instances where humanity is tested and examples of the script at play. Looking at the Tyrell Corporation, the creators of replicants, they designed these humanoids essentially to do the bidding of “real humans.” Whether this is for labor, combat, or pleasure, the replicants are tools for humanity rather than real humans. They have implanted memories, emotions, and other things that you might define as human; however, this is essentially product design and does not count as real humanity. Another literal test of humanity in this film is the Voight-Kampff Test, which is administered to distinguish replicants from humans. It measures responses physiologically and emotionally to determine the empathy of the test subject. While replicants are given memories and other things, they do not have the capacity for empathy, which diminishes their humanity in the eyes of the scriptwriters, the Tyrell Corporation.
Both of these works contribute to the cyberpunk genre’s goal of blurring the line between machinery and humanity. Cognitive, emotional, and biological lines are crossed and call for readers and watchers to truly reflect on what it means to be human. These works push us to think past our view of humanity as a set of physical and biological facts. Being human is determined by who is in power in these worlds, and the unsettling truth is that we could be facing that same control in our future.
References: Gibson, W. (1984). Neuromancer. Ace Books.Scott, R. (1982). Blade Runner: The Final Cut. In vudu.com. https://www.vudu.com/content/movies/details/Blade-Runner-The-Final-Cut/129093
AI Attestation: I used AI to edit this post. https://chatgpt.com/share/6987f068-2770-800d-b360-57cd4fe788e3